top logo
   

Newing Hall - Kirba Comparison

I will start by declaring once again that all opinions are just that, my personal opinions. All machines have good and bad points, it is down to each engraver to determine where their personal preferences lie. Please wait for images to load

newing hall base unit
This is the traditional Newing Hall base unit. The flatbed engraver sits on top of the base,which also utilises the cylindrical attachment. This is raised and lowered on a lage diameter rod. The photo below clearly shows how the two central pillars move together on a machined slide. The clearance is taken up by grub screws acting on shims. Over time, these components do wear allowing excessive movement. Though when the threaded screw is tightened to grip the cylindrical object, this is movement is taken up. I recomend stripping this assembly down yearly for a good clean and grease round, re-adjust the shims as required. After 6 or 7 years of daily use, cosider replacing the threaded rod & brass nuts.
The vice assembly holding the two vertical pillars is affixed to the large rod by a single bolt, shown on the right. This design does not really give enough support to the cylindrical attachment resulting in lack of rigidity, especially if the item to be engraved is heavy. The big other problem is the lack of available tilt. This may not be a major problem for many workshops, but for my application it is
newing hall vice
The Kirba base unit is shown right. The machine is currently set up for cylindrical engraving. Obviously either a TLC or Apex controller can be used, the flatbed unit being the same. The two upright pillars can be adjusted along the central spar. The clamping method are the two black knurled knobs at the front.
kirba base
kirba vice unit
This is a close up of the vice assembly holding the long central spar. The two small levers either side of this spar clamp it in position, whilst the handle at the front tilts the entire mechanism. The large orange handle at the front moves the assembly up and down. The black knobs either side lock this mechanism. This is a substantial unit which provides a solid base on which to mount the item to be engraved
tilted

This demonstrates the maximum amount of tilt that can be achieved, not a procedure I would use very often, but it shows how much more versatile the base unit is

Click here for more illustrations of Kirba jigs and parts